I'd give 5 stars for cut of the tank and material, but I ordered the brown stripe and as others have mentioned, it is more of a pale yellow and the brown has burgundy undertones. I tried to take a picture to include with the review but the colors don't photograph accurately (so I can understand why the model's looks different).

Love the fabric, it is a bit on a smaller side. Was unexpected to see the background of the brown stripe yellow, not off-white but very yellow. Have not decided yet if I want to keep it due to color, but definitely keeping it in white, very versatile tank

Comments about Heavyweight Slub Cotton Tank

The tank offers a unique color combination that works with denim, olive/army greens and bronze. The fit is perfect offering good cover and cropped just below the waist. The fabric provides great structure yet not too heavy for hot weather.

Just a heads up, the background of the brown stripe is very yellow. So sad about that. Otherwise, the shape of these tanks is exactly what I wanted, and the off-white (ivory?) is perfect. I hope the ivory color is used for a few more tees/ tanks this year. Also: these are definitely a thick slub knit for cold ac or spring/fall weather, too heavy for summer. Bought my usual L, tall girls may want an extended size, or go up one if torso length is usually an issue for you.